checklists, not verdicts

Money claims Updated 6 min read By InfoProductReview Editorial

Earnings Claims and the FTC: Reading Income Promises

Short answer

Under US rules an earnings claim must be truthful and backed by evidence, an ad showing unusual income should say what buyers generally earn, and sellers of business opportunities must hand over a written disclosure (with an earnings statement if they make claims) at least seven days before you pay; a wider rule covering coaching and money-making courses was proposed in January 2025 but we found no final version as of November 2026.

"My students made $2.3 million last year." "Replace your salary in 90 days." "Here's my Stripe dashboard." Income promises are the engine of the make-money course business, and they're also the part regulators have written the most about. This guide explains what US rules say about those claims, which rules apply to which products, and how to turn all of it into questions you can put to a seller.

It's an explainer, not legal advice. Rules change, so each section says what we verified and when.

What counts as an earnings claim?

Any statement or image that suggests how much money a buyer can make is an earnings claim, whether it's a number, a screenshot, a testimonial or a lifestyle photo.

The FTC reads ads for their overall impression. "Six-figure students" is a claim. So is a video shot beside a rented sports car with "this course changed my life" in the caption. A claim doesn't need a dollar sign to count, and it doesn't stop counting because a disclaimer appears somewhere lower down.

What do the Endorsement Guides say about income testimonials?

When a testimonial shows results that buyers generally won't get, the ad should clearly say what buyers generally do get.

The FTC revised its Endorsement Guides (16 CFR Part 255) on June 29, 2023, the first update since 2009. The 2009 version had already removed the old safe harbor that let advertisers show extraordinary results with a "results not typical" note. The 2023 text keeps that approach and widens what counts as an endorsement, including reviews, tags and posts by influencers. Advertisers can be liable for their endorsers' claims, and endorsers can be liable for their own.

For you, the practical reading is short: one student's $40,000 month tells you about one student. If the page doesn't say what the median buyer earned, ask.

When does the Business Opportunity Rule apply?

It applies when a seller offers a paid opportunity and says it will supply locations, outlets, accounts or customers, or buy back what you produce; most courses that only teach a method don't meet that definition.

Where it does apply, the rule in 16 CFR Part 437 is strict:

Requirement What it means for you
Disclosure document A one-page form with litigation history, cancellation policy and references, delivered at least 7 calendar days before you sign or pay
Earnings statement If the seller makes any earnings claim, a written statement with the claim, the period, how many buyers got it and what share of all buyers that is
Substantiation The seller must have written evidence for the claim when it's made
No contradictions Nothing said in the pitch may contradict the disclosure document

Some "business in a box" offers, like done-for-you stores that come with suppliers or accounts, may fall inside the rule. A pure video course on running ads usually won't. That gap is the reason for the 2025 proposals.

What did the FTC propose in 2025, and is it final?

In January 2025 the FTC proposed widening the Business Opportunity Rule to cover business coaching and other money-making opportunities and proposed a separate earnings-claim rule for multi-level marketing; as of November 2026 we found no final rule for either.

The proposals would require sellers of those opportunities to back up and keep records of their earnings claims. They were voted out 3 to 2 days before the change of administration, and commentators at the time called their future uncertain. We searched the FTC's rulemaking pages and legal coverage in November 2026 and found nothing showing either one finalized. Treat them as proposals. The general ban on deceptive claims under Section 5 of the FTC Act applies today regardless.

What else is already in force?

The FTC's rule on consumer reviews and testimonials (in effect since October 21, 2024) and its 2021 Notices of Penalty Offenses both give the agency sharper tools against fake income proof.

  • Consumer reviews and testimonials rule (16 CFR Part 465). Bans fake testimonials, including ones attributed to people who don't exist or who didn't have the experience, and bans buying positive reviews. Knowing violations can bring civil penalties. The FTC sent its first warning letters under the rule to 10 companies in late 2025.
  • Notices of Penalty Offenses. In October 2021 the FTC sent notices about money-making claims to more than 1,100 businesses, including many that sell coaching and courses. A company that received one and then makes the listed kinds of deceptive claims can face civil penalties.

How should you read an income claim on a sales page?

Ask four things: whose result is it, over what period, is it revenue or profit, and how many buyers does it represent?

  1. Whose result? The seller's own income from selling the course is not evidence the method works for buyers.
  2. What period? A best month is not a year.
  3. Revenue or profit? Ask what ad spend, software and contractors cost.
  4. Out of how many? "Over 300 success stories" means little without the total number of buyers.

The pre-purchase questions tool turns these into an email when you tick "income or business results". If the seller answers clearly and in writing, that's a good sign in itself. If they reply with another screenshot, you have your answer.

What should you do if a claim looks false?

Save the evidence, ask for a refund in writing if you bought, and report it to the FTC and your state attorney general.

Screenshots with the date and address bar visible are the most useful thing you can keep. Then see our report-a-scam page for where to send them, and refunds and chargebacks for getting money back.

Frequently asked questions

Is 'results not typical' enough to make an income testimonial legal?

The FTC doesn't treat it as enough. Its Endorsement Guides, revised in 2009 and again in June 2023, say an ad that shows results people generally won't get should clearly disclose what they generally will get.

Does the Business Opportunity Rule cover online courses?

Usually not. The rule covers opportunities where the seller says it will provide locations, outlets, accounts or customers, or buy back what you make. A course that only teaches a method normally falls outside it, which is why the FTC proposed widening the rule in 2025.

What is an earnings statement?

Under the Business Opportunity Rule, a seller who makes an earnings claim must give buyers a written statement with the claim, the time period, how many buyers achieved it and the share of all buyers that represents, among other details. Ask for the equivalent even when the rule doesn't apply.

Where do I report a misleading income claim?

In the US, at ReportFraud.ftc.gov and with your state attorney general. Keep screenshots with dates. Our report-a-scam page lists other countries' agencies.

Sources

  1. 16 CFR Part 437: Business Opportunity Rule
  2. FTC: Business Opportunities guidance
  3. 16 CFR Part 255: FTC Endorsement Guides
  4. FTC blog, January 2025: Concerned about deceptive earnings claims? SOS: FTC wants your feedback
  5. FTC press release (October 2021): FTC puts businesses on notice that false money-making claims could lead to big penalties
  6. FTC: Notices of Penalty Offenses

Rules and platform policies change. Facts here were checked in November 2026; check the source before you rely on a detail. Educational only, not legal advice.